The 5 Best Mushroom Popcorn Products: A Review Guide

By Eve Simmons •  Updated: 03/05/21 •  11 min read

Popcorn is a snack that has been loved by kids and adults for centuries. This snack is especially popular in movie theatres because it is so easy to munch on these fluffy treats without needing to tear your eyes away from the screen.

Popcorn is especially tasty if you drizzle these treats in candied sauces like syrup and caramel. If you ever tried to make your own drizzle or coated popcorn at home, you will quickly notice that it isn’t that easy at all.

These popcorn kernels always have a way of becoming soggy, or they break off into tiny pieces.The main reason you are struggling to make coated popcorn at home is that you are using the wrong brand.

Popcorn kernels are available in two main types:

Butterfly popcorn – These are commonly found in stores. It is a light and fluffy popcorn that pops open into odd shapes.

Mushroom popcorn – The kernels are smaller and they produce popcorn pieces that are rounder (like a mushroom), firmer, and a bit chewy.

Mushroom popcorn is better suited for coated popcorn because the pieces don’t get soggy. This is also the preferred popcorn for many people who hate to get popcorn pieces stuck between their teeth.

5 Great-Tasting Mushroom Popcorn Products to Try

There are quite a few different businesses that sell mushroom popcorn kernels that you can make at home. When you are buying mushroom popcorn, it is important to buy from a reputable brand.

Professional brands like the ones we included in this list, usually sell higher quality kernels. The pop rate of the kernels is much higher so you will have hardly any corn left at all after popping. You are guaranteed to get round and fluffy popcorn instead of the odd-shapes of butterfly popcorn.

Here is a quick look at some of the best ones to get now.

1. Double K Popcorn Mushroom Popcorn

Double K Popcorn is a perfect buy if you prefer popcorn in a bottle that you can easily pour into the pot or microwave popcorn bowl.

This product comes in a 30oz plastic jar with a pop-open cap that allows you to pour your kernels with one hand.

The product includes 100% kernels without any artificial ingredients. When you pop this popcorn, you will get good quality mushroom popcorn pieces in average sizes.

The product doesn’t include any seasoning but this can be a good thing because you can add any spices or sauces you like to create a unique tasting product.

Before you can pop this corn, you will need to measure out the needed amount and add it in a popping device such as a pot, popcorn machine, or microwave popcorn bowl.

Specifications:

Pros

Pros
  • Includes 100% whole grain popcorn
  • Produces high quality mushroom popcorn
  • The corn is perfect for sweet coatings
  • The 30-ounce bottle produces a lot of popcorn
  • It is a good quality product
  • Very easy to pop
  • You can add any type of seasoning

Cons

Cons
  • Not available in a microwave bag
  • No seasoning included

VIEW ON AMAZON

2. Great Northern Popcorn Mushroom Popcorn

If you are buying in-bulk, then this gigantic 50-pound pack by Great Northern Popcorn is an ideal investment.

The huge pack of popcorn is stored in a moisture-proof bag that will keep your kernels fresh and dry.

The bag includes fine quality kernels that will produce round or mushroom-shaped popcorn pieces that taste fantastic. One bag of popcorn will produce up to 800 ounces of popped corn pieces.

The popcorn is free from spices, flavorings, and artificial ingredients. With this popcorn, you can choose whether to create salty popcorn, cheesy popcorn, sweet popcorn, or any other popcorn recipe you might have in mind.

The bag includes loose popcorn kernels which means you will have to measure out your corn before you add them to a pot, microwave bowl, or popcorn machine.

Specifications:

Pros

Pros
  • The 50 pound bag is a nice bulk pack for businesses
  • The pack only includes mushroom popcorn kernels
  • Once popped, you will have round, fluffy popcorn
  • It is a good quality product
  • The popcorn is easy to pop
  • The kernels are neutral so you can add any seasoning you like
  • Produce up to 800 ounces popcorn from just one bag

Cons

Cons
  • The paper bag can get wet on the outside
  • It is not available in microwave-ready bags
  • No seasoning included

VIEW ON AMAZON

3. Reist Popcorn Company Hi-Pop Mushroom Popcorn

This is another good bulk buy if you want to produce a lot of popcorn.

The 50-pound bulk pack can produce up to 800 ounces of fine quality popped corn pieces.

This popcorn is free from flavorings, colorants, or other artificial ingredients. They are fast to pop and produce mushroom-shaped pieces that are ideal for making sweet popcorn treats with syrups and sauces.

You can, of course, also add salt and spices to create a popcorn with the usual butterfly popcorn taste.

Specifications:

Pros

Pros
  • The bulk pack is ideal for saving money or for businesses
  • Mushroom popcorn produced is nice and round
  • Quality corn kernels are selected
  • The popcorn is perfect for sweet coatings
  • Very quick and easy to pop
  • It is a gluten free product
  • No seasoning is added so you can create any flavor you like

Cons

Cons
  • No microwave-ready packets included
  • No seasoning included
  • The paper bag can get wet on the outside or stained

VIEW ON AMAZON

4. Hoosier Hill Farm Gourmet Mushroom Popcorn

This is another good bulk pack if you need high-quality gourmet popcorn.

Hoosier Hill Farm is known for their fine quality products and they outdid themselves with this great quality product.

Their popcorn isn’t the cheapest, but only the finest quality kernels are included in the package. When you pop this corn, you will get mushroom-shaped corn pieces that taste fantastic. This popcorn is ideal for creating luxury sweet popcorn treats such as unicorn popcorn, caramel popcorn, and many others.

Specifications:

Pros

Pros
  • The 25-pound bulk pack is perfect for stocking up
  • Quality popcorn kernels are included
  • The product includes 100% mushroom popcorn kernels
  • The product is easy to pop
  • The pack produces high yields
  • This is a gourmet popcorn that is rich in flavor
  • The round popcorn pieces is ideal for sweet coatings

Cons

Cons
  • The popcorn is a bit pricey
  • Does not include microwave ready packs
  • Does not come with seasoning

VIEW ON AMAZON

5. Princeton Popcorn Mushroom Popcorn Kernels

Mushroom popcorn tends to be smaller than butterfly popcorn pieces. But these giant popcorn pieces by Princeton popcorn are specially cultivated to produce bigger pieces of up to ¾ inches in size.

The popcorn comes in a plastic bottle with a large lid. The sealed bottle keeps the kernels fresh and dry and the large lid makes it easy to get a measuring cup into the bottle so you can scoop out the needed amount.

The popcorn will pop into round mushroom-shaped pieces that are ideal for making fine quality sweet treats with all sorts of coatings. The product is flavor-free so you can create any flavor popcorn you like.

Specifications:

Pros

Pros
  • The popcorn kernels are extra-large at about ¾ inches in size
  • The corn pops into nice mushroom shaped balls
  • It is an ideal popcorn for sauce coatings
  • The product is neutral so you can add any flavoring or seasoning you like
  • Very easy to pop
  • It is a quality product
  • The popcorn is light and tasty

Cons

Cons
  • No microwave-ready packs included
  • No seasoning included

VIEW ON AMAZON

Buying Guide for Mushroom Popcorn

You will quickly note that most of these popcorn products look pretty similar. That is because they are made of the same ingredient: 100% mushroom popcorn kernels. So, how do you choose the best one? Perhaps this handy buying guide can help you decide.

The Best Giant Mushroom Popcorn

Mushroom popcorn typically is smaller than butterfly popcorn. If you want mushroom popcorn that is nice and large, then you should consider Princeton Popcorn’s mushroom popcorn kernels. This corn variety is specially cultivated to produce larger popcorn pieces and results in extra-large popcorn snacks for every kernel you pop.

The Best Bulk Mushroom Popcorn Packs

If you are buying popcorn in bulk, then you should consider the 50-pound packs by Great Northern Popcorn or Reist Popcorn Company. These bulk packs are affordable and ideal for companies that need to produce lots of fine tasting popped corn at an affordable price.

The Best Gourmet Popcorn

The bulk popcorn pack by Hoosier Hill Farm is a bit pricier than your average bulk pack because it is a gourmet product that produces higher quality corn pieces that handle coatings better compared to some brands. You can consider this brand if you want to produce high-quality treats.

The Best Bottled Mushroom Popcorn Packs

Lots of people prefer small quantities of popcorn to ensure that none of their product goes to waste. Bottled popcorn is also easier for many to handle since you can just take the cap off and pour your kernels in without struggling with any annoying bags.

Our list includes two great bottled popcorn products to consider; The Double K Popcorn and the Princeton Popcorn. Both of these are terrific for making fine tasting treats, although you should consider Princeton Popcorn if you prefer bigger popped pieces.

How to Pop Mushroom Popcorn

Making mushroom popcorn is just as easy as making butterfly popcorn. There are quite a few different ways you can make the popcorn but the following two methods are the best.

Stovetop Mushroom Popcorn

To make your popcorn on the stove, you should heat 3 tablespoons of oil in a large pot on medium heat. Oils with a high smoke point like peanut oil, soy oil, sunflower oil, light olive oil, or coconut oil are ideal. When your oil is hot, you can add 1/3 cup of popcorn kernels. Place a lid on your pot to keep your corn from jumping all over the kitchen.

You can now move the pan to stir the popcorn kernels inside so they can turn for even heat distribution. Moving your pan also keeps your popcorn from burning. You will soon hear the popcorn start to pop. Cook for 2 – 4 minutes or until you hear the pops slow down up to 5 seconds apart before removing it from the heat. Your popcorn is now ready to serve.

If your oil isn’t heated at a high enough temperature, you can end up with butterfly-shaped popcorn.

Always ensure that your oil reaches 400 degrees before adding your corn.

Microwave Mushroom Popcorn

To make popcorn in a microwave, you will need to mix 1/3 cups of kernels in 1 tablespoon of oil.

Place the mixture into a brown paper bag and fold over the top two times. Now give the bag a good shake. Place the bag in the microwave and cook for 2 minutes or until the corn stops popping.

Final Thoughts

We hope that this guide helped you find great tasting mushroom popcorn that is healthy and easy to make. And if you are also on the market for other great mushroom products, or if you need more hints and tips, then we welcome you to have a look at some of our other articles and guides.

Have a nice pop!

Eve Simmons